火针刀与火针治疗带状疱疹的疗效比较
火针疗法,治疗疾病效果不错
第13卷 第2期 2011 年 2 月
辽宁中医药大学学报
JOURNAL OF LIAONING UNIVERSITY OF TCM
Vol. 13 No. 2 Feb .，2011
火针刀与火针治疗带状疱疹的疗效比较
唐胜修，王小莲，刘辛，韦春华
（广西壮族自治区人民医院星湖门诊部，广西 南宁 530022）
摘 要：目的：比较火针刀与火针治疗带状疱疹的疗效。方法：带状疱疹患者43例，按随机数字表法分为火针
刀组23例和火针组20例，火针刀组以火针刀治疗，火针组以火针治疗，然后分别统计两组的全部结痂时间和疼痛强度变化，并加以比较。结果：火针刀组全部结痂时间明显少于火针组（P<0.05），治疗后火针刀组疼痛强度评分明显少于火针组（P<0.05），火针刀组治疗后疼痛强度评分明显少于治疗前评分（P<0.05）。结论：火针刀治疗带状疱疹疗效优于火针治疗。
关键词：火针刀；火针；带状疱疹
(2011) 02- 中图分类号：R752.12 文献标识码：B 文章编号：1673-842X 0089- 02
Efficacy Comparison of Herpes Zoster Treatments with
Cauterized Needle-Knife and Cauterized Needle
TANG Sheng-xiu，WANG Xiao-lian，LIU Xin，WEI Chun-hua
（Xinghu Out Patient Department，People's Hospital of Guangxi Province，Nanning 530022，Guangxi，China）
Objective：To compare the herpes zoster treatment efficacy of cauterized needle-knife Abstract：
43 cases of herpes zoster patients were divided into 2 groups according and cauterized needle. Methods：
with random number table method，23 cases of cauterized needle-knife group（group 1）and 20 cases of cauterized needle group（group 2）. After the 2 groups were treated respectively，add up the whole scab time and changes in pain intensity of the 2 groups respectively，then make statistical comparison. Results：
，the After treatments，the whole scab time of group 1 was significantly lower than that of group 2（P<0.05）
，and after treatment，the pain pain score of group 1 was significantly lower than that of group 2（P<0.05）
The herpes zoster treatment score in group 1 was significantly less than the pre-treatment score. Conclusion：
efficacy of cauterized needle-knife was superior to that of the cauterized needle.
cauterized needle-knife；cauterized needling；herpes zosterKey words：火针治疗带状疱疹疗效显著[1]。火针刀技术治
疗带状疱疹与火针治疗带状疱疹有根本区别，本文
[ 11 ] 任国谱，张人明，彭灿，等.牛乳“上火”机理探讨[ J ] .中国
乳业，2003，46 ( 11 )：17-19.
[ 12 ] 杨锋.春天宝宝上火危害大[ J ] .开卷有益：求医问药，2010
( 4 )：7-9.
[ 13 ] 黄玉广，赵军.食用蛋白粉上火机理研究[ J ] .食品研究与开
发，2004，25 ( 1 )：151-152.
[ 14 ] 吴安华，谢明霞.发炎是怎么回事[ J ] .人生与伴侣(月末版)，
2008 ( 10 )：25.
[ 15 ] 沈施德.阳虚火炎证治浅识[ J ] .辽宁中医杂志，1993，20 ( 8 )：
16-17.
[ 16 ] 刘炳凡.阅食物“上火”的机理初探-水分子氢键与“上火”
的关系一文后小识[ J ] .湖南中医药导报，1997，3 ( 1 )：11.
[ 17 ] 良子.春天药膳帮你灭火[ J ] .人人健康，2010 ( 6 )：67.
[ 18 ] Robert A. Greenwald. Oxygen radicals, inflammation, and
arthritis: Pathophysiological considerations and implications for treatment [ J ] .Seminars in Arthritis and Rheumatism，1991，20 ( 4 )：219-240.
[ 19 ] S. Al-Assaf, S. Navaratnam, B.J. Parsons, G.O. Phillips. Chain
scission of hyaluronan by carbonate and dichloride radical anions: Potential reactive oxidative species in inflammation?[ J ] .
Free Radical Biology and Medicine，2006，40 ( 11 )：2018-2027.[ 20 ] Peter A. Ward, Jeffrey S. Warren, Kent J. Johnson. Oxygen
radicals, inflammation, and tissue injury[ J ] .Free Radical Biology and Medicine，1988，5 ( 5-6 )：403-408.
试图通过对带状疱疹的治疗来比较二者的疗效，作
为对火针刀治疗带状疱疹技术的深入探讨。
[ 21 ] Elaine M. Conner, Matthew B. Grisham, Inflammation, free
radicals, and antioxidants[ J ] .Nutrition，1996，12 ( 4 )：274-277.
[ 22 ] M.Goss-Sampson, A.J.Vivian, F.J. Kelly，Free Radicals,
Inflammation and Eye Diseases [ J ] .Immunopharmacology of Free Radical Species，1995 ( 1 )：127-142.
[ 23 ] Bertram Poch, Frank Gansauge, Bettina Rau, et al. The role of
polymorphonuclear leukocytes and oxygen-derived free radicals in experimental acute pancreatitis: mediators of local destruction and activators of inflammation[ J ] . FEBS Letters, 1999, 461 ( 3 )：268-272.
[ 24 ] M.Yeadon. Free Radicals in Lung Inflammation and
Environmental Exposure to Pollutants[ J ] .Immunopharmacology of Free Radical Species，1995 ( 2 )：215-232.
[ 25 ] Cheng-Chung Cheng,Yi-Hsin Chen,Wen-Liang Chang,et al..
Phytoestrogen bavachin mediates anti-inflammation targeting I [kappa] B kinase-I [kappa] B [alpha]-NF-[kappa] B signaling pathway in chondrocytes in vitro[ J ] . European Journal of Pharmacology，2010，636 ( 6 )：181-188.
[ 26 ] Hirasawa N, Goi Y, Tanaka R, Ishihara K, et al. Involvement
of prostaglandins and histamine in nickel wire-induced acute inflammation in mice[ J ] .Journal of Biomedical Materials Research Part B: Applied Biomaterials，2009，93A ( 4 )：1306-1311.
收稿日期：2010-09-14基金项目：广西中医药管理局中医药民族医药标准化课题（GZBZ0910）作者简介：唐胜修（1966-），男，广西桂林人，副主任医师，硕士，研究方向：针灸治疗临床疾病。
89
